Best Alternatives to MTD for builders in 2025
MTD for builders is a free checker that helps self-employed CIS subcontractors in the UK work out whether Making Tax Digital for Income Tax applies to them from April 2026, 2027 or 2028, based on their qualifying income. It is a focused, single-purpose tool, so tradespeople who want broader accounting, tax filing or business support often look at alternatives. The options below cover free HMRC services, accounting software with MTD tools, and specialist CIS and construction finance apps.
HMRC Making Tax Digital guidance and eligibility tools
The official source for MTD for Income Tax rules, thresholds and sign-up. Free and authoritative, though less tailored to the specific income patterns of CIS subcontractors than a builder-focused checker.
FreeAgent
Popular with UK freelancers and small limited companies, with MTD-ready bookkeeping, invoicing and Self Assessment support. Good if you want one place to track income and prepare for digital filing, though it is not CIS-specific.
Xero
A full cloud accounting platform with MTD for Income Tax support and a large app marketplace. Strong for builders who want proper bookkeeping now and a clear route into digital tax filing, but it has a monthly cost and a learning curve.
QuickBooks
Widely used by UK sole traders and small construction businesses, with MTD-compatible tools, receipt capture and Self Assessment reporting. A practical step up from a free checker if you need ongoing records rather than a one-off eligibility answer.
Coconut
Designed for self-employed people and sole traders, with income tracking, expense capture and tax estimates. Simple and mobile-friendly for subbies who want to monitor qualifying income through the year, though construction-specific features are limited.
Sage Accounting
Established UK accounting software with MTD for Income Tax support and payroll options. A sensible choice for builders who expect to grow, take on staff or move to a limited company, but it is more than many sole traders need.
CIS-specific payroll and subcontractor apps
Tools built around CIS verification, deductions and subcontractor statements can complement an MTD checker by keeping the income records that feed the qualifying income test. Useful for subbies working across multiple contractors, though they usually focus on CIS compliance rather than MTD eligibility itself.
MTD for builders is a quick free way to check which Making Tax Digital start date applies to you. If you only need a yes-or-no answer on thresholds, HMRC's own guidance is the natural backup. If you want to track income, keep digital records and prepare for MTD filing, FreeAgent, Xero, QuickBooks, Coconut or Sage are stronger long-term choices, while CIS-specific apps help with subcontractor paperwork. Most self-employed builders will get the best result by using a free checker first, then choosing accounting software once they know their start date.